|
Copyright 2004, Business Week
Pretty Liberal With The Cash
Ron Burkle puts his celeb Rolodex to work for a social agenda -- and CalPERS
By Christopher Palmeri in Los Angeles
What do rap music impresario Sean "Puff Daddy" Combs and former
Vice-President Al Gore have in common? Los Angeles money manager Ronald W. Burkle
backed each of them with cash from the California Public Employees' Retirement
System.
Nobody cultivates the rich and famous quite the way Burkle does. The 51-year-old
billionaire frequently hosts celebrity-packed charity events at his Beverly
Hills estate. He has given millions of dollars to political causes, most of
them connected with the Democratic Party. Even former President Bill Clinton
is on his team, serving as a senior adviser to Burkle's investment firm, Yucaipa
Cos., in return for a slice of the profits. But can Burkle turn his A-list Rolodex
into high-powered returns for California pensioners?
In the past three years, CalPERS has committed up to $760 million to Burkle
for investments that aim to help underserved segments of society while, of course,
still making money for the retirement fund. He has been putting the money to
work in a string of deals that he says will benefit minorities, women, and blue-collar
workers. Last year, Burkle invested an undisclosed amount in Sean John, the
urban-sportswear company founded by Combs. In May, he was one of the backers
of Gore's planned $75 million cable-TV station, INdTV, which aims to provide
news and entertainment for 18-to-34-year-olds. And in August, he paid $300 million
-- some of it CalPERS money -- to buy TDS Logistics Inc., a Canadian auto-parts
concern that had been hit by a strike the month before.
Burkle argues that the Combs and Gore deals not only reflect his social mission
but are also good commercial investments. Combs's apparel business, he says,
is one of the nation's fastest-growing companies, reaching nearly half a billion
in sales in just six years. With Gore, Burkle says he was able to invest in
a cable station -- currently running Canadian news -- at a very low price because
cable operators had yet to renew their subscriptions. After Gore laid out his
business plan, the cable operators quickly re-upped. Burkle says both companies
employ minorities and women and are creating jobs in urban areas. In the case
of TDS, Burkle brought in a Yucaipa labor-relations specialist to help settle
the strike, which resulted in wage increases, adjustments in workers' shifts,
and a commitment from the management to resolve several workplace issues. "We've
gotten great returns by treating people well," Burkle says.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
The son of a grocery-store manager, Burkle made a fortune in the 1980s and '90s
buying and selling supermarket chains such as Ralphs Grocery Co. and Dominick's
Finer Foods Inc. He says the rewards of socially conscious investing outweigh
the risks. After the 1991 riots in Los Angeles, for example, Burkle says he
spent $50 million to rebuild damaged stores and keep workers employed. Those
stores were later part of a 1998 merger between Fred Meyer Inc. and Kroger Cos.
(KR ) that netted Burkle $1 billion. In choosing him to manage money in May,
2001, CalPERS said Burkle had earned an average annual return of 45% over the
preceding 13 years. How much CalPERS makes won't be known until the investments
are sold in a few years.
The money committed to Burkle is a small part of CalPERS' portfolio. The nation's
largest pension fund, with $166 billion in assets, CalPERS provides health-care
and retirement benefits to 1.4 million current and former government employees
in California. Three years ago, it began a big push into socially responsible
investing. Burkle was one of 11 advisers chosen from among 67 who applied to
manage this money. He got $200 million to invest in capital-starved urban and
rural markets. A year later, CalPERS committed as much as $560 million more
for Burkle to invest in companies managed in ways that don't hurt labor.
Burkle's deals also illustrate how the line between business, social connections,
and politics can be blurred as pension funds come under increasing pressure
from labor unions, politicians, and activists to pursue goals other than simply
making money. Gore has said that his new network will not espouse any particular
political beliefs. But the deal was brought to Burkle by San Francisco venture
capitalist Richard Blum, another INdTV investor, whose wife is Democratic Senator
Dianne Feinstein.
Burkle says he and Combs have been friends for about eight years -- since their
meeting at a party at Burkle's house. Combs recently entered the political fray,
starting a get-out-the-vote drive with the slogan, "Vote or Die!"
PARTY ANIMALS?
These relationships strike some observers of the pension-fund world as just
a little too cozy. "We should be concerned as taxpayers," says Stephen
M. Bainbridge, a professor of law at the University of California at Los Angeles.
"I don't want them making investment decisions so they can get invited
to Puff Daddy's next party or advance their political agendas."
CalPERS declines to comment, but Burkle says that is certainly not the case.
And he says winning his contracts from CalPERS was equally above board. He says
he never has used his connections to influence the awarding of state money-management
contracts. Still, he told BusinessWeek, he will no longer contribute to the
campaigns of the California governor, state treasurer, or controller while he
pursues new business with CalPERS. Since 1999, Burkle has contributed more than
$600,000 to campaigns for state office.
His focus, he says, is entirely on making money for California's pension system
and bettering life for those less fortunate than him. "If I want to live
in this big house, I have to feel good about myself," he says, sitting
in the living room of his 32,000-square-foot mansion while a white-coated attendant
serves him cranberry juice. California taxpayers better hope so.
By Christopher Palmeri in Los Angeles
|