Home 用中文 Espaņol  
News & Opinion
Legal Hotline
Membership
Asked & Answered
Access To Meetings
Access To Records
News Gathering
Prop 59
CFAC Podcasts
Model Letters
Books
AG Opinions
CFAC In The News
CFAC Assembly
About Us
Contact Us


Enter your e-mail to receive our bi-weekly FLASH newsletter:




Right to photograph in public/private forums 

Q: We have been told by a small-community postmaster, and a higher-up in a regional office, that we cannot photograph the inside of the tiny lobby for a story about small community life. They say it is "our policy" but will cite no specific law. We've also asked for access behind the window to shoot a picture of a clerk helping a customer. Same answer. Any legal prohibition here? What would be the result if we push the point and photograph in the lobby anyway?

A: Your right to take photographs (or engage in other activities protected by the First Amendment) generally depends on whether the location in question can be characterized as a “public forum.”  Under federal court interpretation of the First Amendment, post offices generally are not considered to be public forums.  See, e.g., United States v. Kokinda, 497 U.S. 720 (1990); Burrus v. Vegliante, 336 F.3d 82, 91 (2d Cir. 2003). 

California courts have occasionally construed the California Constitution as applying more broadly, but there is no published California case law extending constitutional protection to photography or other newsgathering activities inside a post office.On the other hand, at least the front portion of the post office is apparently open to the public.  There is nothing to prevent you from entering and taking pictures.  Your presence is not a trespass.  I am not aware of any statute or regulation prohibiting the taking of photographs in the public areas of post offices (although I have not looked for such provisions so I cannot rule them out either).  Once you have taken the pictures, attempting to prevent their publication would be a prior restraint, which is presumptively unconstitutional.

 

join


Have a legal question?
Check out Asked & Answered first. Chances are, we've already answered it. If not, then proceed to CFAC's Legal Hotline for help from top lawyers—free.


CFAC Archives:


Search CFAC
Google
WWW cfac.org